Mirrors & Trumeaux · identification & value
Antique French Mirrors in NYC
In the Gilded Age, New York families furnished their Fifth Avenue houses in the French manner, and Paris decorating firms such as Jules Allard et Fils opened branches in the city. Gilt overmantels and trumeaux crossed the Atlantic by the shipload, and New York has been a market for French mirrors ever since.
1750–1900
Typical asking price on live listings
about $22
Median of current eBay asking prices (via PicClick); listings run from $1.4 to $5,200. Asking prices are not sold prices.
Expert tip
Look at the back of the glass where it meets the frame: 19th-century tin-mercury plates have a soft, unpainted grey back that should not be touched, while silver-nitrate plates carry a red or grey protective paint. A dealer who knows which one he is selling is a dealer worth trusting.
History
- French gilt mirrors of the Louis XV, Louis XVI, Empire and Napoleon III periods were imported to New York in large numbers in the late 19th century.
- Today New York dealers, the Winter Show at the Park Avenue Armory and online galleries continue to sell 18th- and 19th-century French mirrors.
Where it comes from
The mirrors themselves come from Paris, Lyon and provincial French gilders and trumeau makers; New York is where many were imported, from the Gilded Age onward, and where specialist dealers still sell them.
Details to look at
- Style of the cresting: Louis XV rocaille shells and C-scrolls, Louis XVI ribbons, urns and pearls, Empire palmettes, or Napoleon III mixtures of all of them.
- Gilding: water gilding over gesso and red bole, oil gilding, or later bronze paint; burnished highlights against matte grounds.
- Glass: tin-mercury or silver plate, original or replaced, flat or bevelled, single plate or two plates joined.
The market: most wanted
- 18th-century Louis XV and Louis XVI giltwood mirrors with their original mercury plates.
- Large Napoleon III overmantel mirrors from Paris apartments, 2 m or more high, with cast and carved crestings.
- Louis XVI trumeaux with original painted panels or overdoor-style canvases above the glass.
Authenticity: period piece or reproduction?
- Water gilding was burnished on raised areas and left matte in the recesses; where it has worn, red or yellow bole shows through, while gold paint wears to white gesso or bare wood.
- The back should be wide pine or oak boards, darkened and shrunk, with hand-made nails or old screws; Paris carvers and gilders sometimes left paper labels or chalk marks.
- The plate on a 19th-century mirror is held by wooden blocks or glazing pins, and on large mirrors it may be made of two plates joined at a bevelled seam, a sign of period manufacture.
- Warning signs: modern 'French-style' cast-resin mirrors with uniform ornament, a frame regilt in bright metallic paint, new glass with printed foxing, and dealers unwilling to show the back.
Where to buy
- In France, Saint-Ouen, Drouot and Proantic sell the same mirrors before export; buying there and shipping can save on a New York retail mark-up.
- In New York, Upper East Side and downtown antiques dealers, the Winter Show and The Salon Art + Design; online through 1stDibs and Chairish with NY-based galleries.
Buyer's checklist
- Silvering type
- Gilding
- Back boards
- Plate fixing
Facts
- Typical size
- H 100–250 cm · W 70–160 cm
- Weight
- 15–60 kg
- Period
- 1750–1900
- Materials
- Giltwood, gesso, gold leaf, pine, mercury or silver mirror plate
- US search interest
- 230 searches a month
Collector interest
US shoppers type 230 searches a month about nyc, spread over 4 keyword variants.
Searches by country of origin: french (150).
Related in Mirrors & Trumeaux
- Antique Mirror
- Antique Vanity Mirror
- Antique Dresser Mirror
- Vintage Wall Mirror
- Antique Venetian Mirror
- Vintage Bathroom Mirror
- Full-Length Mirror
- Vintage Floor Mirror
Go deeper: research notes
The Antique Mirrors: An Identification Guide gathers 12 sourced object studies, including:
- The psyché mirror in Morisot’s painting: a tilting dressing mirror in context
- Venetian mirrors with engraved panels: reading a composite surface
- A pocket-sized mirror in tortoiseshell and silver
See also: Antique French Trumeau Mirrors.