French Vintage FurnitureThe collector's encyclopedia · identification & prices

Garden Iron & Metal · identification & value

Wagner Cast Iron

At the turn of the 20th century, almost every American kitchen had a cast-iron skillet, and many came from a foundry in Sidney, Ohio. Wagner's pans were cast thin and machined smooth on the inside, which made them light for their size. Now collectors hunt them at estate sales for their cooking surface, which many find better than modern rough-cast pans.

1891–1960

Typical asking price on live listings

about $66

Median of current eBay asking prices (via PicClick); listings run from $2.5 to $4,995. Asking prices are not sold prices.

Expert tip

Lay the skillet on a flat surface and press each edge: if it rocks or spins on its base, it is warped and won't heat evenly on a flat stove; then tap the rim and listen for a clear ring rather than the dull note of a crack.

History

  • The Wagner Manufacturing Company was founded in Sidney, Ohio, in 1891 and became one of the two great American cast-iron makers with Griswold.
  • The company changed ownership in the 1950s, and later production under different owners is less sought after.

Where it comes from

Not French: Wagner cast iron was made by the Wagner Manufacturing Company of Sidney, Ohio; the French equivalents are the enamelled cast-iron cocottes of Le Creuset (Fresnoy-le-Grand, from 1925) and older cast-iron marmites from French foundries.

Details to look at

  • Markings on the base: Wagner Ware logo, 'Sidney -O-', size number and pattern number.
  • Cooking surface smooth from milling, not rough sand-cast.
  • Heat ring on the base and handle shape.

The market: most wanted

  • Early Wagner skillets with the stylised logo and Sidney mark.
  • Rare forms: chicken fryers, waffle irons, large skillets.
  • Wagner aluminium and cast-iron pieces in good condition.

Authenticity: period piece or reproduction?

  • Older Wagner pans have smooth machined interiors and crisp lettering.
  • Reproductions and late pieces have rough textured surfaces and blurred marks.
  • Old seasoning shows as even black patina, not paint.
  • Warning signs: cracks hidden by heavy seasoning, warped bases, pitted surfaces after rust, and fake marks on imported cast iron.

Where to buy

  • In the US, estate sales, eBay, flea markets and cast-iron specialist dealers.
  • In France, look instead for Le Creuset and old foundry cast iron at regional brocantes and on Leboncoin.

Buyer's checklist

  • Flat base
  • No cracks
  • Clear markings
  • Smooth surface

Facts

Typical size
Skillets Ø 15–35 cm
Weight
1–5 kg
Period
1891–1960
Materials
Cast iron, some aluminium
US search interest
1,700 searches a month

Collector interest

US shoppers type 1,700 searches a month about wagner, spread over 1 keyword variants.

Material searches favour cast iron (1,700).

Related in Garden Iron & Metal