Chests & Trunks · identification & value
Vintage Tool Chest
A French journeyman carpenter on his Tour de France carried his tools from town to town, and many made their own chest as a showpiece: dovetailed oak, sometimes with inlaid compass and square on the lid. In American factories, machinists kept their precision instruments in oak Gerstner chests with felt-lined drawers, closed by a front panel and one key.
1850–1970
Typical asking price on live listings
about $1,049
Median of current eBay asking prices (via PicClick); listings run from $12 to $18,995. Asking prices are not sold prices.
Expert tip
Open the lid and look for the maker's plate or decal: Gerstner chests carry a brass or paper label inside the lid or on the front, Kennedy chests a stamped name on the steel; then check that the lock bar (the front panel that slides up into the lid) is present, as many chests have lost it.
History
- Wooden carpenters' and joiners' chests were standard tradesmen's furniture in France, England and America through the 19th century.
- H. Gerstner & Sons began making oak machinist chests in Dayton, Ohio in 1906; Kennedy made steel chests in Van Wert, Ohio from the early 20th century.
Where it comes from
France for joiners' and carpenters' wooden chests (caisses à outils, coffres de menuisier), often made by the craftsman himself during his Tour de France as a compagnon; the US for machinists' chests by H. Gerstner & Sons (Dayton, Ohio, 1906), Kennedy Manufacturing (Van Wert, Ohio) and Proto (Los Angeles).
Details to look at
- Dovetailed corners, iron or brass corner guards and chest handles.
- Interior: sliding trays, tills, felt-lined drawers.
- The lock, the key and, on machinist chests, the front lock panel.
The market: most wanted
- Gerstner oak machinist chests with all drawers, felt and front panel.
- French compagnon-made chests with decorated lids and trade symbols.
- Vintage Kennedy and Proto steel chests in original wrinkle finish.
Authenticity: period piece or reproduction?
- Hand-cut dovetails have uneven spacing and scribe lines; machine dovetails are identical.
- Old wood chests show tool wear inside, ink and pencil marks, sometimes the owner's name.
- Gerstner drawers have finger-jointed corners and green felt lining.
- Warning signs: new plywood drawer bottoms, relined felt in bright colours, repainted steel chests sold as original and missing keys.
Where to buy
- Leboncoin, regional brocantes and vide-greniers for French wooden tool chests; tool-collectors' fairs for complete chests.
- In the US, eBay, estate sales and tool auctions for Gerstner, Kennedy and Proto chests; check the shipping weight before buying.
Buyer's checklist
- Maker's label
- Lock and key
- Drawers complete
- Felt condition
Facts
- Typical size
- L 50–100 cm · D 25–50 cm · H 25–60 cm
- Weight
- 8–40 kg
- Period
- 1850–1970
- Materials
- Oak, pine, steel, brass hardware, felt
- US search interest
- 140 searches a month
Collector interest
US shoppers type 140 searches a month about tool chest, spread over 8 keyword variants.
Most-searched materials: wood (20).