Antique Demijohns · research note
Demijohn pontil scars: why a familiar dating shortcut can fail
A pontil scar is evidence of a stage in glassmaking. Its presence on a demijohn does not supply the same narrow date range that a collector might associate with a different kind of bottle.
A documented exception
The BLM/Society for Historical Archaeology bottle reference warns that some specialised bottles continued to be made with older techniques after those techniques had largely disappeared from ordinary utilitarian bottles. It explicitly includes demijohns and carboys among vessels that can retain pontil scars later than a simple dating rule would suggest.
Identify the evidence precisely
Record the base as a whole and then the suspected scar. Distinguish a manufacturing feature from a modern chip, and avoid touching a sharp area to test it. A wicker cover may prevent examination; that limitation belongs in the description. Do not remove a fragile covering simply to obtain a more complete set of photographs.
Use a group of observations
A useful assessment considers the finish, body, seams, base and documented history together. The SHA reference concentrates principally on North American bottle identification, so its broad chronological patterns should not be transferred uncritically to every European demijohn. Its warning is nevertheless directly relevant: a long-lived specialised form may preserve a manufacturing technique beyond the period in which it was usual elsewhere. Record what the scar demonstrates and leave the exact date qualified.
Questions and answers
Does a pontil scar automatically make a demijohn early nineteenth century?
No. Specialised vessels can preserve older manufacturing techniques later.
Explore this collection
Sources
Research checked 18 October 2026. Museum comparisons do not authenticate objects offered elsewhere.