French Vintage FurnitureThe collector's encyclopedia · identification & prices

Vases & Art Glass · identification & value

Hobnail Milk Glass Vase

In the 1950s, American brides received white hobnail milk glass vases by the dozen, made in West Virginia glass factories. A century earlier, French glassworks in Lorraine produced opaline vases in white, pink and green, painted or gilded for the mantelpiece.

1850–1980

Expert tip

Hold the vase up to bright light: 19th-century milk glass and opaline often show an amber-red 'fire' at the edges, mid-century American milk glass usually does not; and Fenton pieces made from 1970 carry an embossed 'Fenton' in an oval under the base.

History

  • Fenton hobnail milk glass was produced in quantity from the 1950s; Fenton marked its glass with an oval logo from 1970.
  • French opaline was made at Baccarat and in Lorraine glassworks in the 19th century; Portieux and Vallérysthal merged in 1872.

Where it comes from

Not French in its best-known form: hobnail milk glass vases are American, from Fenton (Williamstown, West Virginia), Westmoreland and Anchor Hocking; the French equivalent is opaline from Portieux and Vallérysthal (Lorraine) and Baccarat.

Details to look at

  • Hobnail pattern: round raised bumps in even rows, with a crimped, ruffled or flared rim.
  • Colour: dense white, Jadeite green (Anchor Hocking's Fire-King), or Jeannette's Shell Pink of the late 1950s.
  • Base: the embossed Fenton oval (from 1970), remains of a paper label, or a ground pontil on older opaline.

The market: most wanted

  • Pre-1970 Fenton hobnail vases with original paper labels, especially large fan and ruffled shapes.
  • Jeannette Shell Pink and Fire-King Jadeite vases in clean condition.
  • 19th-century French opaline vases from Baccarat, Portieux or Vallérysthal with hand-painted flowers or gilding.

Authenticity: period piece or reproduction?

  • Old milk glass shows fine scratches and wear on the base ring from use.
  • Mould seams on American pressed glass are fine and even, never sharp.
  • French opaline is lighter and more translucent than American milk glass, with hand-applied decoration.
  • Warning signs: newer reissues with ground-off marks, chalky over-white glass, and reproductions of Jadeite with a too-bright green and no wear.

Where to buy

  • Brocantes, Leboncoin and L'Isle-sur-la-Sorgue for French opaline; occasional American milk glass at Saint-Ouen.
  • In the US and UK, eBay, Etsy, antique malls and estate sales, where hobnail milk glass is plentiful.

Buyer's checklist

  • Marks
  • Fire test
  • Chips on crimps
  • Colour

Facts

Typical size
H 10–30 cm
Weight
200 g–1.5 kg
Period
1850–1980
Materials
Milk glass, opaline, opalescent glass
US search interest
180 searches a month

Collector interest

Milk vase draws 180 monthly US searches, split into 8 keyword variants.

Material searches favour glass (180).

Related in Vases & Art Glass